Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer in Noir

          My sister used rimmel's exaggerate eye definer eyeliner for awhile and it was because of her that I started using this liner a little more a year ago. The eyeliners that I have used in the past smears a lot and her eyeliner barely smudges so I wanted to give this a try.
          This rimmel's exaggerate eye definer eyeliner is a retractable pencil and has a sharpener and smudger on the tip. Also, this liner is waterproof and said to be able to last for 10 hours. I have never put on just eye liner (always with primer and eyeshadow).  However, for a few days last year I didn't have time to put on eye shadow so I just put on primer and this liner. My sister always put on just eyeliner (no primer) all the time so I figured that I can do that too since her liner barely smears. Unexpectedly, the top of my eye lids was covered with smeared eye liner by the end of the day(wasn't really happy about that...). I thought to myself maybe this liner isn't for me.
          But I decided to use it again since I have not used this liner with eyeshadow.  This time around my lids looked perfectly fine and the liner didn't smear on them.  My waterline did smear though, but it was definitely not as bad compared to the liners I used in the past.  From this experience, I found out that my eyelids are not suitable with just eyeliner and primer.  I have to use primer and eyeshadow together in order to have smear proof eyeliner.
          I generally use this eye liner for quick makeup in the morning, formal events and on the go touch ups.  This eye liner does get dry, but it will be fine after sharpening.  Overall, this eye liner is a good buy for such good quality.